
This is a glass of Merlot. In the background is a glass of Guiness and a jar of water.
I made this picture big on purpose, because this is the elephant in the proverbial diet room.
Before I start, I really want to preface this with a little personal background. You’re welcome to skip this part if you just want the nuts and bolts.
<BLAH BLAH>For reasons that I would never begin to know how to replicate if I were to rear my own children (would I even want to replicate this??), disinterest in alcohol was constant for me straight through high school, college and years beyond. My friends in high school were generally straight-laced, studious and hard-working and alcohol was not a part of my high school experience. I thought of myself as an artist, an athlete and a bit of a health nut, so it just wasn’t part of the identity I was creating for myself.
In college, I had a wonderful, amazing roommate who would not touch alcohol or any other substance – even, eventually, at her own wedding. She remained my closest friend straight through college and had a big influence on my day-to-day life at Drew. My first-hand introduction to excesses of alcohol consumption at the collegiate level was limited a brief study-abroad stint in the beautiful Republic of South Africa and Homesickness. I immediately recovered from this slight binge upon my re-entry to the United States.
My general philsophy was that as an athlete, alcohol was bad for my performance; as a female, it was bad for my sense of control; as a rabid music fan, it detracted from the shows I attended; as a writer, it was bad for my creativity and focus; and as a burgeoning foodie, it was bad for my wallet.
Life gets in the way sometimes, though.
In the last few years, I did start drinking socially. I found I have an almost hobby-level appreciation for craft beers and I’ve learned to enjoy a glass or two of red wine with friends. On the flip side though, I’ve been nurturing a writer’s block almost a decade old, I stopped making time for music and I don’t really compete at anything athletic anymore. I’m not going to say that one caused the other. I teach correlation vs. causation twice a year at Riverdale and this is definitely the former. However, there’s a reason I’ve put them together in this paragraph.
Starting with my entrance into graduate school, I began to drink alone while writing my papers. Then, while reading. Then, starting last July, I found myself drinking almost every night, no matter what it was I was doing, because I thought it was actually making me feel better. I’m not saying I was an alcoholic. I wasn’t. I’m just saying that this is where our discussion of diet and alcohol begins. </BLAH BLAH>
I first became aware of the issues that alcohol presents anyone on a controlled diet when I was probably around 10 and on WeightWatchers. Now, as far as I’m concerned, no 10 year old should ever be on Weight Watchers. If you want to have me rant at you about it sometime, leave a comment letting me know and I’ll buy you a coffee to nurse while I do so. For the time being, let’s all move along.
At the time, WeightWatchers didn’t allow alcohol (it has begun allowing it since) – In fact, during meetings (EVERYONE had to go to meetings when I was in WeightWatchers, even the 10 year old), there would be whole blocks of time dedicated to how to deal with social functions and alcohol. Given the fact that I was 10, this seemed strange to me – if it’s bad for you and stops you from reaching your goal, why would you still feel the need to have it? <insert your and my inability to clearly and universally answer this question here>
This theme has continued with every programmed eating plan I’ve tried since – alcohol is always an issue, right down to my most recent stint reading Robb Wolf’s wonderfully accessible The Paleo Solution. This guy keeps talking about his freaking Nor Cal Margaritas! And, if we look at my diet reading in July, it’s freaking Tim Ferris and his general prohibition of alcohol except for an Rx of 2x Red Wine every day. What now? SO CONFUSED.
I don’t really have an answer to this – Robb Wolf suggests distilled liquor if you’re going to drink. It seems like most folks on Paleo forums will make occasional allowances for dry wines (dry = less sugar) or hard ciders. Some even brought up Mead, which is honey-based.
Since breaking my mostly-teetotalling streak of childhood to early adulthood and breaking into drinking like an American adult, I’ve found it hard to go back to how it was. Not because of my weird July-October wine binge, but because I’ve realized that the 13 holes I’ve put in my body, the two unrepaired menisucus tears, the bike crashes, the yard sales, the bruises on my arms in my prom pictures (fencing, people! fencing!), the book and tooth I chipped in a mosh pit are all related to Robb Wolf’s NorCal Margaritas. Even though I’ve never met Robb Wolf. In a weird, but really not so weird way, it’s a celebration of life. We can’t be perfect all the time – we occasionally need to trainwreck ourselves, or even just trip ourselves up a little to let loose and really appreciate the relationships we’ve made, the physical health we’ve maintained, or the goals we’ve met (or worked at and missed). It’s silly for me to fear loss of control, to feel holier-than-thou at shows, to think I’m such a great athelte that my performance suffers so much – or to think that writing without a little liquid courage isn’t warranted occasionally.
I’m not drinking as I write this – I haven’t had a drink in weeks. But, I did just finish a good Friday night class with a slight twinge in my lower back and it got me thinking about what it is I’m doing – the thesis, the paleo, the crossfit, the skiing, the job, the relationships, the life. That’s why Robb Wolf says to go ahead and have a NorCal Margarita. That’s why Tim Ferriss likes his two glasses of Merlot every night. And that’s why I like my sports, my music, my writing – and even, in moderation, my wine and beer. Because they all make life a little more interesting, a little more tolerable, and they make planet earth a more pleasant place to spend 85 years – and isn’t that why we’re doing all this paleo shit in the first place?
So, have a glass when your favorite beer is on tap. If you’re working hard, you deserve it, and life is good.